Planar magnetic loudspeakers
There are a variety of different drivers used in over-ear headphones, each with their own unique characteristics. The two most common types of drivers in headphones are dynamic and planar magnetic. Dynamic drivers have been around since and are by far the most commonly used type of driver for both headphones and loudspeakers. If you ever took a pair of headphones or a speaker cabinet apart just for fun, it almost certainly had the large magnet and paper cone of a dynamic driver.
===We are searching data for your request:
Planar magnetic loudspeakers
Wait the end of the search in all databases.
Upon completion, a link will appear to access the found materials.
Content:
YOU CAN STILL ADD MORE!
New customer? Create your account. Lost password? Recover password. Remembered your password? Back to login. Already have an account? Login here. Andrew Park 9 minute read. You may have come across a number of headphones that are advertised as having "planar magnetic" drivers. But the question is, what does this mean? Is planar magnetic better? A planar magnetic driver or transducer the device that converts the electrical signal to sound waves functions differently from dynamic drivers in that it uses a flat diaphragm rather than a typical cone or dome shaped membrane that you might find in common loudspeakers.
The planar diaphragm also has a conductor trace on that allows it to react to the magnetic field produced by magnets on one or both sides of the diaphragm. This made them quite heavy over g. Over the years, designs have been improved and refined, both when it comes to how thin the diaphragm is the thinner the better and to the rest of the structure, allowing for single-sided magnetic arrays and other methods of making the headphones lighter.
Modern planar magnetic headphones have benefited from these innovations in ways that also yield improvements to sound quality over their predecessors, however there are certain characteristics of some of those older models that enthusiasts still prefer. Dynamic drivers by contrast use a more traditional design with a cone or dome shaped diaphragm connected to a moving voicecoil.
The voicecoil is moved by a charged magnet structure behind it. Dynamic drivers also vary in terms of how they're designed. Higher-end dynamic driver headphones from Focal for example use what they call a "formless" voicecoil, meaning the moving piece is much lighter and able to react faster to the signal it's being given.
In this case, there's no center column that the voicecoil fits around, reducing overall mass. So the most recognizable difference is the flat diaphragm of planar magnetic transducers, but the other key difference is the conductor trace for planar magnetic headphones is fixed on the diaphragm, while dynamic drivers have a conductor voicecoil behind the diaphragm.
Both driver types function in a pistonic motion to produce sound waves, however the planar advantage of having the conductors directly on the flat surface of the diaphragm allow it to react more evenly within the magnetic field. In the past, planar magnetic headphones were what you had to get in order to have good bass response - they were the only ones that had full bass extension down to 20hz, while dynamic drivers would commonly roll off below 50hz.
These days, however, some enthusiasts actually prefer the bass response of dynamic driver headphones. The reason for this is that while you do get inherently better bass extension with planar magnetic headphones, many modern planars don't have quite as much punch or slam as dynamic driver counterparts. However the trend for many newer planar headphones is that often what they gain in terms of efficiency and comfort compared to their older counterparts, they lose in dynamic impact the 'punch' or slam quality.
At the moment, it's unclear to me what causes this difference, it may be due to the prevalence of single-sided arrays with less magnetic force being exerted on the diaphragm, or it could be due to physical properties of the diaphragm itself.
As technology advances, we're getting thinner and thinner material for the diaphragm, and this allows planars to become more efficient, and also use lighter magnets so that they're lighter overall. But this trade off also may be responsible for less slam and punch. He indicated that there are several different factors that play a role in this. You can watch the video below:. Conversely, dynamic driver headphones have improved as well to be able to produce frequencies all the way down to 20hz - even the open-back ones previously it was possible but only with closed-back designs.
Even still, in most cases, planar magnetic headphones often have a more linear bass extension than dynamic driver headphones, even if dynamic driver headphones now have the ability to extend all the way down to 20hz. This means the advantage is still there to some extent, resulting usually in a more 'clean' sounding bass response - even if the headphone in question may not punch as hard as high excursion dynamic driver headphones, like the ones from Focal for example. Other advantages include better image structure and clarity.
This leads to the ability to isolate individual instrument lines in the mix better with planar magnetic headphones. When it comes to detail retrieval, it's not quite as straightforward however. There are a number of dynamic driver headphones like the Focal Utopia, that make use of unique materials like Beryllium or other design innovations to achieve incredible detail retrieval as well.
Generally this is imparted by the stiffness and rigidity at the diaphragm's center - especially for treble frequencies - remember that dynamic driver diaphragms are not uniform the way planar magnetic diaphragms are. So in summary, headphones with planar magnetic transducers often sound tighter, more controlled, and have better extension capabilities with less distortion for bass than dynamic drivers.
There's a unique 'plucked' quality to the way tones come across, and in general, planar magnetic headphones are better at instrument separation and distinction.
Modern high end dynamic driver headphones by contrast often have a bit better 'punch' or 'slam', even if they don't have as good image clarity and distinction capabilities although often still quite good. Planar magnetic transducers also impart a certain type of sound or 'timbre' that makes them immediately recognizable as planars. In some cases they can sound a bit less familiar than what we might be used to with typical dynamic driver transducers, whether in headphones or speakers.
Lastly, another common distinction identified by listeners is that dynamic driver headphones often do a better job of even and consistent image distribution across the center of the stage. What I mean by this is that rather than a pan from left to right having an immediate crossover in the middle, there's a more gradual and consistent pan across the stage.
There are enough exceptions and counterexamples here where this likely isn't an inherent limitation to planar magnetic driver headphones, but rather that currently there are a number of planar magnetic headphones that don't do this as well as dynamic driver headphones.
It's important to remember that planar tech hasn't been nearly as common as dynamic drivers, so it's likely just a matter of figuring out what works best for image distribution - and there are a number of them that do this very well, like the HiFiMAN Ananda and Arya for example. This brings me to another interesting point of distinction. Many listeners who prefer dynamic driver headphones will report that they have a more 'natural' sound to them.
There are even those who claim that when it comes to the ultra high end, planar magnetic headphones like the LCD-4 and Susvara are too good at image separation, clarity, detail, representation of fast transients - to a degree that detracts from the 'realism' of the music being listened to. Or in other words, there's a natural decay to the way instruments sound, and this is perhaps better represented in dynamic driver headphones. There are two ways to think about this distinction in my opinion.
The first is to conclude that dynamic driver headphones do indeed sound more 'natural and realistic'. The second is to remember that we're also much more used to hearing music through equipment with dynamic drivers, in both speakers and headphones. This familiarity may be the reason for the sense of realism.
I think the answer to the question of which driver type sounds more realistic may instead come down to the question of whether 'realistic' entails "speakers in a room", or the way we naturally hear sound in the world. If it's the latter, then perhaps planar magnetic transducers do actually perform better. To answer the initial question of "is planar magnetic better? Do you value image structure, clarity and distinction?
Or do you value punch and slam? Do you want that 'plucked' character of planar magnetic sound? Of course, there are enough exceptions where you don't have to make any concessions one way or another - and not just at the highest price bracket. It may not be as detailed or refined as some of the higher end options, but it's a great all-rounder that anyone considering getting into planar magnetic headphones should probably start with.
Conversely, there are enough dynamic driver headphones out there these days that also give you excellent bass extension, detail retrieval, imaging etc. With all of that said, my preference leans slightly towards the planar magnetic sound when done well, particularly for those advantages, even if I don't currently own any.
What does this mean? Well for me, at a given price bracket, if there's a choice between a dynamic driver headphone and a planar magnetic headphone, I often find myself preferring the planar.
But you may have different priorities, and so you have to answer that question for yourself. Getting your product to you as fast as possible is important to us! And it's free! Does not apply to special-order, open-box or sale items. Create your account Lost password? First name.
Last name. Your cart is empty. Andrew Park 9 minute read You may have come across a number of headphones that are advertised as having "planar magnetic" drivers. Design Differences A planar magnetic driver or transducer the device that converts the electrical signal to sound waves functions differently from dynamic drivers in that it uses a flat diaphragm rather than a typical cone or dome shaped membrane that you might find in common loudspeakers.
You can watch the video below: Conversely, dynamic driver headphones have improved as well to be able to produce frequencies all the way down to 20hz - even the open-back ones previously it was possible but only with closed-back designs. Observations This brings me to another interesting point of distinction. Conclusion To answer the initial question of "is planar magnetic better? Looks like you've changed your theme and now DropInBlog's code needs to be re-added to your theme files.
Follow these instructions to solve this right away. Or hit us up on Messenger if you'd like some help. Real, Human Support Reach out to us through our handy live chat or by e-mail.
Planar Speakers
New customer? Create your account. Lost password? Recover password. Remembered your password? Back to login.
AES E-Library
JavaScript seems to be disabled in your browser. You must have JavaScript enabled in your browser to utilize the functionality of this website. Planar magnetic speakers significantly outperform traditional speakers in both sound clarity and distance. Menu Search Cart. Wireless Head Sets Corded Headsets. Intuity Audix Voice Mail. Bogen Amplifiers Poweramp. Industrial Intercom System.
News & Events
Store is open from 10 am to 6 pm today. Planar Magnetic technology is ushering in a new era of incredible sound quality based on this older component structure. To the delight of ears around the world, a few specialized HiFi audio headphone companies have begun to create masterpieces in recent years that use old school planar drivers instead of common, coiled dynamic drivers most headphones and speakers utilize. A hybrid of electrostatic and typical dynamic driver styling, Planar Magnetic designs are known for exceptionally rich bass, albeit at the cost of a spacious sound signature.
Who invented planar magnetic?
User Name Stay logged in? How do you create a planar diaphragm? Hello guys! I'm new to this forum. This lead me to become interested in Planar magnetic loudspeakers.
How Speakers Work
Journal of Vibroengineering, Vol. This paper presented a low cost flexible electro-dynamic planar loudspeaker FEPL with coils on polyimide diaphragm. The structure was very simple to put a flexible thin film diaphragm electroplated traces of copper coil above a flexible magnetic placed in the bottom of cavity , thus forming an integration of electromagnetic actuation and planar flexible structure. The advantages are as follows: 1 the new loudspeaker became a flat flexible one, which could not only directly drive the vibration film to increase the power efficiency, but reduce the total harmonic distortion THD. To optimize the performance of sound pressure level SPLs , this study made detailed analyses on the thickness of cavity, turns of coil, magnet polarization, and diaphragm dimension.
These planar-magnetic elements are capable of covering nearly the full audible frequency range with low distortion, controlled diaphragm resonances, and without dealing with multiple drivers and crossovers. This project involves disassembling the satellites and installing the planar-magnetic elements in compact speaker enclosures to fully realize their potential and to eliminate need for the subwoofer and its built in stereo amplifier. Why not use the stock system? The output from the rear of planar magnetic elements is degrees out of phase with the front output.
We offer ready-to-listen, semi-custom, and fully custom loudspeakers for professional installation. All models feature our unrivalled planar magnetic high-frequency drivers and only the highest quality of low-frequency speaker cones. Explore some of our options below. All weather loudspeakers built to the highest standards and ready for professional installation. Regardless of it you choose a sound bar beneath a television, a full outdoor surround sound system, or an altogether custom home cinema, our products combine immaculately.
The planar magnetic speaker is a type of speaker closely related to the electrostatic speaker. It is nearly identical in radiation concept to an electrostatic loudspeaker, having a large, thin, vertically orientated plastic diaphragm as the vibrating element. Planar speakers use conventional magnetic principles, however, and are, therefore, dynamic loudspeakers. Thin wires from a plastic diaphragm form an equivalent of a voice coil stretched out lengthwise. Magnetic strips are placed in the front and back of the diaphragm, where the stators would be in electrostatic loudspeakers. Magnetic instead of static interaction causes the diaphragm to vibrate.
A Planar Technology Primer. If you're younger that 30, it probable that the term "planar transducer" is not part of your vocabulary. And likewise, unless you studied physics in college, the concepts of "planar theory" would be equally foreign to you. Planar magnetic technology was first developed in the 's during the same decade that conventional cone speakers were created.
You are mistaken. Let's discuss. Write to me in PM, we will communicate.
This post, is incomparable))), it is very interesting to me :)